My relationship with Yellowjackets over the past couple of seasons has been complicated. While the freshman run stands tall as an absolute masterpiece of modern television, Seasons 2 and 3 stumbled significantly, particularly when navigating the contemporary timeline.

As the narrative gears up to conclude with Season 4, viewers must now juggle three distinct eras instead of two: the current adult timeline, the immediate aftermath of the rescue, and the untold period bridging last season's cliffhanger and that ultimate extraction. This third timeline receives just a single scene in the premiere: Natalie (Sophie Thatcher), newly reconnected with civilization, sprints down the mountain shouting excitedly that rescue is on the way.

She halts abruptly as pure horror washes over her face. "What the $*#^?" she exclaims, before the credits roll.

Shauna Continues To Be Awful

In the present-day narrative, Shauna (Melanie Lynskey) has retained a private investigator to track down Melissa (Hillary Swank), though he has yielded zero results. She threatens him with violence, harasses a gas station attendant, and generally throws her weight around like a common thug. Frankly, I am thoroughly exhausted by Shauna in every single iteration.

Meanwhile, adult Taissa (Tawny Cypress) and adult Misty (Christina Ricci) share that profound fatigue and are actively plotting Shauna’s demise. We are treated to brilliantly clever sequences featuring Misty prowling around Shauna's house, envisioning various ways to stage a fake suicide, with Lynskey physically acting out these scenarios on screen. It serves as a delightfully dark window into Misty’s warped psyche.

When Misty heads out to purchase a firearm using Shauna’s identity, she conjures an imaginary scenario where Shauna murders Jeff (Warren Kole) and then takes her own life—the classic murder-suicide angle. "Ti’s not gonna like it," the imaginary Shauna warns Misty. I genuinely hope she fails to eliminate Jeff; he remains one of the few surviving characters I actually root for. And spare a thought for his poor shirts!

We also encounter a compelling sequence where Taissa performs a candle ritual that mentally transports her back to the wilderness. She spots the familiar symbol carved into a tree before teen Van (Liv Hewson) materializes and grasps her hand—her eyes initially appearing strange enough to make me mistake her for the eyeless man.

As Van stares at something off-screen and asks, "What is that?" with palpable fear in her voice, Taissa jolts out of her nightmare trance, utterly terrified. In my view, the series squandered the Other Taissa storyline terribly after the first season, and keeping Van alive essentially to replace Tai’s family felt like a misstep. Even so, I am genuinely intrigued by where this plot thread leads.

Elsewhere, Melissa packs up her family and flees. She confesses to making up the name Kelly and admits her entire backstory was a fabrication, omitting the fact that she not only met her mother but was present when she died. Later, we see them unpacking in a new home, leading us to believe they have relocated far away to start fresh. However, that proves entirely false. She has moved into the house directly adjacent to Shauna’s. The truth drops when she brings over a welcoming bottle of wine. "Now I know where you are," Shauna remarks. "Now everyone will," Melissa fires back as a news van rolls up outside. Once again, I am eager to see where this narrative goes.

This ranks among the strongest adult-timeline material we have seen since the first season, though I am hesitant to raise my expectations too high. The fundamental hurdle to wrapping up this timeline satisfyingly is the absence of adult Natalie. A part of me wishes they had recast the role once Juliette Lewis departed. She wanted off the show, but killing her off in the modern timeline strips the story of its premier—and perhaps only—true protagonist. Natalie serves as the closest thing this show has to a hero, and without her, the adult timeline simply fails to click entirely, even when the writing improves as it did in this episode. Recasting is notoriously difficult, especially for someone as singularly unique as Lewis, but I remain convinced it was the correct path forward. Her death was handled so poorly that I am still angry about it years later.

The creative team also severely mishandled adult Lottie (Simone Kessell) before killing her off, much like they did with Van. Lottie could have been developed into an infinitely more mysterious, menacing, and wild presence. Season 1 concluded with the earth-shattering reveal that she was still alive, seemingly having kidnapped Natalie, only for her to end up running a New Age wellness retreat.

The storyline functioned best when the survivor count was lower, and I deeply wish the original four were still with us.

Breaking News: Traumatized Teenagers Rescued From Wilderness

The rescue timeline offered plenty of intrigue, even if active plot progression was minimal. The episode title, Hivemind, references the girls' uniform, word-for-word responses during interrogation. Their stories are perfectly aligned, yet the investigator can sense something is deeply amiss. While the Canadian government attempts to uncover the fate of the missing researchers alongside the truth of the girls' survival, they are stonewalled and ultimately bullied by the U.S. ambassador into sending the youngsters home.

Understandably nervous about boarding an aircraft, the teens are swarmed by aggressive journalists shouting questions and flashing cameras as they board. Lottie suddenly wheels around and screams. Among all the survivors, Lottie (Courtney Eaton) appears the most withdrawn, closely followed by Shauna (Sophie Nelisse)—who denies ever having a baby in the wilderness when questioned by doctors, despite overwhelmingly definitive proof to the contrary.

Witnessing their reintegration into civilization is undeniably fascinating, albeit bleak and depressing as it highlights just how brutal the adjustment to reality proves to be. I remain uncertain how heavily this season will lean into that timeline; ideally, the focus won't linger there too extensively, because the dark, untamed menace of the wilderness is where this narrative truly belongs to unravel its twisted mysteries.

Altogether, this marks a robust return for Yellowjackets. Let us simply hope the momentum holds. While I doubt we will ever recapture the sheer perfection of the inaugural season, I would be entirely satisfied if this chapter stands as the runner-up. The previous two seasons offered isolated bright spots—mostly within the wilderness sequences—but failed to bring us closer to the answers we crave. Perhaps the ultimate truth of what transpired out there will remain forever hidden. Time will tell.