The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 5 Review: A Stumbling Hour
As The Rings of Power drops its fifth and sixth episodes, the fallout from the five-year time jump established at the start of Season 2 continues to shape the narrative. This temporal leap appears primarily designed to ensure every corner of Middle-earth and Númenor learns of the One Ring, secretly forged by Sauron, portrayed by Charlie Vickers. The narrative device also conveniently forces universal recognition onto Gandalf, played by Daniel Weyman, despite the wizard only discovering his own moniker last season thanks to the Harfoots dubbing him Grand Elf.
Lore Inconsistencies and the Power of the Rings
Lacking pointy ears, the wizard's classification stretches logic in a world where distinctive ears supposedly separate elves from men. Meanwhile, Sauron—retaining his pointy ears for reasons unexplained—has conquered vast swaths of Middle-earth off-screen, leaving his motivations for needing the One Ring muddled. In Tolkien's lore, the One Ring was forged in Mordor to dominate the other rings, whereas the show introduces a chaotic dynamic where human fighters instantly transform into black-robed thralls, bypassing the subtle, chilling corruption depicted in the source material.
Despite working directly alongside elven smith Celebrimbor last season, Sauron spends much of the early episodes hunting for crafting knowledge. The storyline sees the new orc leader Marnûkh, played by Adam Young, leading Galadriel and Arondir to Gundabad to rescue an elven smith, only to find Celeborn, played by Jamie Campbell Bower, imprisoned instead. Following a narrow escape on an eagle, Arondir is struck down by the newly minted dark knight Theo, narrowing the representation of elven characters on screen as Episode 5 commences.
Inside the Hall of the Mountain King
Sauron subjects Marnûkh to intense interrogation, but the loyal orc resists the Dark Lord's pressure. Utilizing subterranean espionage, Sauron discovers Marnûkh has a family and leverages this information to break the orc's resolve, only to coldly dismiss his pleas with the revelation that his children are already dead. Concurrently, Sauron interacts with Theo, setting the stage for further manipulation.
Opting for a grueling trek rather than utilizing avian transport, Galadriel and Celeborn flee their pursuers on foot. Their journey features nostalgic banter and romantic interludes before Galadriel awakens from a nightmare where Celeborn's face morphs into Sauron's. Falling backward from their treetop hideout, she is knocked unconscious, while Celeborn is swiftly recaptured by the tracking orcs.
The Shadow of Thangorodrim
The narrative delves into Celeborn's past imprisonment in Thangorodrim, Morgoth's legendary northern fortress destroyed at the end of the First Age. The history of Angband, its massive volcanic forges, and the War of Wrath provides a dense backdrop, though it raises narrative questions as to why Galadriel never searched the ruins for her missing husband. Sauron twists the knife further, taunting Celeborn with the revelation that Galadriel searched for the Dark Lord instead of him.
Standout Performances Amidst the Chaos
Amidst the narrative turbulence, standout performances emerge from the cast. Robert Aramayo delivers compelling work as Elrond, particularly shining in a poignant sequence alongside his brother Elros, highlighting some of the season's strongest dramatic beats as Elros contemplates his future in Númenor.