The Five Star Stories Manga Volume 1 Review: A Mecha Epic
As one of the most enduring mecha manga series ever conceived, The Five Star Stories has finally made its triumphant return in a brand-new English edition, and the results are nothing short of breathtaking.
It is important to note that this is not the inaugural English translation for the franchise. A previous attempt rolled out over a decade ago utilizing an oversized page layout designed primarily to showcase the intricate artwork. While those legacy volumes remain prized collector’s items, this fresh publication takes a distinctly different approach.
Mirroring the physical dimensions of standard Japanese tankobon editions, the new release flows in the correct reading direction and boasts an entirely revised translation. Certain localized terminology underwent shifts—such as transitioning from Colus to Chorus—adjustments that presumably align with the definitive vision of creator Mamoru Nagano.
When I interviewed Nagano some years back, he expressed his frustration with how meaning is lost between languages when translated. At the time, this was something he was grappling with and likely why the earlier English release was cut short.
This updated translation reads with a marked distinction from past editions, a nuance clearly driven by Nagano’s meticulous editorial oversight.
A Vast Universe of Intricate World-Building
Meticulous is indeed the operative term here. The Five Star Stories unfolds across a staggeringly complex, multi-billion-year timeline that continues to expand as Nagano crafts fresh installments to this day.
Consequently, this inaugural volume shoulders a massive narrative burden, yet the storytelling remains remarkably resilient four decades after its original Japanese debut.
The overarching plot is anchored in the Joker Star Cluster, a celestial territory comprising five distinct star systems. Each system hosts habitable worlds governed by rival kingdoms locked in a perpetual struggle for dominance.
As the narrative opens, the cluster finds itself in a twilight epoch of technology. Even in this diminished state, the remaining machinery commands terrifying power and cosmic scope.
- Mortar Headds: The primary engines of war, serving as the ultimate mecha units.
- Headdliners: The elite warriors chosen to pilot the colossal combat machines.
- Fatimas: Advanced human-type androids engineered to manage the crushing technical complexity required to operate a mortar headd.
Fatimas typically select their own masters, generally pairing male headliners with artificial female androids—a dynamic that might evoke mixed reactions regarding character hierarchy. However, when a premier headdliner bonds with a master-class fatima, their combined combat efficacy becomes an apocalyptic force.
This exact dynamic fuels the core conflict of the first volume, which centers on a renowned geneticist auctioning off his latest two masterwork fatimas to the highest bidders across the star systems.
Legacy, Influences, and Artistic Brilliance
This opening volume also serves as the foundational text for the 1989 standalone OVA anime adaptation. While the manga delivers significantly greater contextual depth—particularly through an opening prologue largely omitted in the cinematic version—the core architectural structure remains identical.
Drawing parallels between this manga and Frank Herbert’s Dune is far from hyperbolic. The intricate political maneuvering, factional warfare, and layered history mirror the court intrigue of Arrakis, executed on an even grander and more convoluted scale.
Fans of classic mecha will also trace thematic threads back to Heavy Metal L-Gaim, the 1980s television series Nagano co-created alongside Yoshiyuki Tomino. Although Nagano maintains that L-Gaim and The Five Star Stories occupy entirely separate continuities, unmistakable crossover elements persist, offering a glimpse into what L-Gaim might have looked like without commercial or budgetary constraints.
Aesthetically, the artwork remains peerless, rendering the mortar headds as some of the most elegantly terrifying mechanical designs ever committed to paper.
Ultimately, Volume 1 successfully accomplishes its foundational mission: welcoming readers into the dangerous, beautiful, and fractal depths of the Joker Star Cluster. The mere existence of this definitive English edition is a milestone worth celebrating for sci-fi enthusiasts worldwide.