Your curiosity has you searching for answers about your company. You want to see what others see—online, but the results aren’t what you hoped. You’ve asked Claude about what the company does. The answers you got might have been right five years ago, but they’re not even close to what your business does now.

You’ve probed your team about the results, and no one is owning the firm’s generative engine optimization or GEO. No one seems to be ensuring AI tools such as ChatGPT and Google’s AI answers describe and recommend the business accurately.

I’ve seen these types of scenarios repeatedly while offering my advice to executive leaders on how their companies appear in the results. GEO isn’t something that can or should be handled 100% in-house. Outsourcing GEO, though, comes with a caveat. Its execution can be delegated, but the story AI repeats about a company cannot.

Why GEO Is A Leadership Decision

Customers aren’t forming a first impression from one of your company’s blog posts. They’re getting it from AI answers and summaries, as a Centerfield GenAI Consumer Survey for Search Engine Land highlights. The survey found 87% of U.S. adults read AI summaries when reviewing search results. They’re not clicking on the blog, the article or the video.

Despite knowing this change in how buyers absorb online information, most companies aren’t ready. The same report found that 93% of marketers struggle to implement GEO. Only 33% rated themselves as good or expert when it comes to understanding GEO.

This gap between knowledge and understanding is why so many companies are outsourcing GEO. But there’s a tangible risk in doing so, which is that leaders hand off the company’s narrative along with the work. That narrative is what AI answers are telling your customers about your company’s brand identity. However, if you work with an agency that’s doing GEO well, you’re giving your company’s narrative a chance to outshine the competition in the overviews.

In my experience advising agencies in the SEO industry, I’ve heard stories of how their clients used other agencies before coming to them for their GEO strategy. A common denominator I noticed from some of them was that their clients had previously been guaranteed specific results with an unrealistic timeline, only to be disappointed when that didn’t happen. I think the most important thing to know when seeking out GEO agencies is that they can’t—and shouldn’t—guarantee the desired results will happen at a time of their choosing. Each client has different needs that require a unique strategy, so agencies should never be promising perfection to clients.

I’ve seen firsthand just how quickly LLMs like ChatGPT, Claude and other AI tools have impacted brands across the board. For this reason, I’ve invested heavily in this area since I view this as the future of most companies’ success, with AI influencing buying decisions and trust. One of our faster-growing portfolio companies is a GEO agency called Relevance, which actually analyzes how each brand they work with is showing up in various AI tools and then crafts a specific strategy tailored to what their prospects are searching for.

In turn, this approach helps brands change the narrative AI tools are presenting to their potential buyers. My concern with AI visibility over a year ago was the lack of trackability of results. However, in the last 6 to 12 months, this has changed significantly, where growth leads and ROI can be tracked a lot better. For example, more case studies show measurable results on how the agency has helped brands grow with actual numbers tied to it. From advising Relevance and other companies, I’ve learned to gravitate to an agency that sets realistic expectations from the start and helps clients better understand how GEO works in relation to their ROI metrics.

Scope The GEO Engagement Around Business Outcomes

You can’t expect a GEO agency to know what your company’s strategic narrative is. The agency’s team needs context, and it’s leadership’s job to give it. A critical part of this context is what business outcomes you’re trying to achieve.

Begin with the questions your buyers ask AI tools about the category your business operates in. You don’t want to start with a list of tactics. Don’t try to control how your company is going to show up in the answers before you’ve outlined what customers are searching for.

Other factors to consider are what outcomes matter. Do you want your content to be recommended for specific questions, desire more accurate product descriptions or need to correct outdated information? Spell out what the GEO agency will take ownership of, whether it’s creating content, reaching out to media, monitoring results or all of it.

Agree on how the agency will report progress back to you and how often. You don’t want to judge success on how many impressions your company received over the past month. Keep in mind AI answers change frequently, so the scope of your partnership with the agency should include regular check-ins instead of a list of fixed deliverables.

Set Governance And Approval Rules Before Your GEO Partner Starts

Governance is oversight, and it’s not a step to skip internally. Determine which staff member will own your brand’s narrative. This is usually someone from marketing, communications or a similar function with the authority to give your GEO partner the direction it needs.

Give the agency a short source-of-truth document that includes approved positioning statements, product facts and language to avoid. Set ground rules on what the agency can say on your company’s behalf and where, including third-party media outlets and online community forums. Decide who signs off on claims about products and the company, especially numbers and anything regulated by outside government agencies.

Successful GEO agency partnerships are also built on transparent workflows. How do deliverables move through the pipeline? Then, match the level of review to the level of risk. Routine updates don’t need C-suite approval, but executive bylines and sensitive topics probably do. Establish review turnaround times so you’re not creating a bottleneck that leads to missed opportunities and targets. A shared online space where drafts, approvals and published pieces live helps ensure nothing goes out unseen. Also come up with a quick process for correcting inaccurate AI answers when they appear so false narratives don’t continue to flourish.

What To Keep In-House When Outsourcing GEO

There are four aspects of GEO I think should stay in-house. Your partner has the implementation expertise, but not the insights about the information you want to present.

The first is positioning and messaging. Your brand’s core story should come from and stay with leadership, not your agency. The second is executive voice and expertise. Your partner can help shape and place it, but the insight has to come from the leaders themselves. The third is customer knowledge. Your sales and support teams know the real questions customers ask.

The fourth is the final say on anything public, including relationships with key media outlets and partners. Up to 90% of the citations behind brand visibility in AI tools can come from earned media, and brands can’t buy placement in the answers these tools give.

Outsourcing GEO Works When Ownership Stays Put

The real test of whether outsourcing GEO is working is measurable results. After handing over the implementation piece, do you get accurate descriptions on what your company does from Claude and ChatGPT? If so, you’re one of the companies that understands outsourcing GEO well. You’ve treated your partner as an extension of your leadership team, not a replacement for it.