Merger synergies are common in theory but relatively rare in practice — research conducted by Deloitte reveals that only 25% of acquirers actually manage to achieve at least 80% of their synergy targets.

TireHub, a leading US tire distributor, has an interesting history. The company was formed by combining the distribution operations of two competitors. I spoke with TireHub in 2020, not long after the company was formed. The logic behind the merger made sense. But what have they actually achieved? I got an opportunity to circle back and find out.

TireHub’s experience suggests a merger built on building better best in class service would grow sales. Service would improve based on a combined supply chain network and technology. For a distributor, this is a much better value proposition than looking to take redundant costs out of a newly combined company.

TireHub and its Supply Chain

TireHub is a U.S. tire distributor with approximately 1,500 employees, up from 1,150 when the company was formed. The company sells to big-box retailers – like Costco, Walmart, and Discount Tire, as well as car dealerships and mom-and-pop automotive repair shops. They sell the passenger and light truck tire portfolios of Bridgestone and Goodyear.

Bridgestone and Goodyear formed their joint venture in 2018 to create TireHub, with each owning 50%. Goodyear, headquartered in Akron, Ohio, has the largest tire market share in the U.S. Bridgestone is the world’s second-largest tire manufacturer after Michelin. They are a Japanese company headquartered in Tokyo.

TireHub was created to combine the companies’ U.S. distribution networks. This gave TireHub the breadth and depth to better compete on speed. The company operates only in the U.S.

The company has 78 tire logistics centers across the country. These buildings range from 30,000 to 70,000 square feet.

The company built three regional distribution centers . Allentown opened in October of 2023, Coppell Texas in October of 2024, and San Bernardino in January of 2025. They range in size from 360,000 to 420,000 square feet.

These larger warehouses serve as mixing centers, combining imported and domestic factory-direct products. They then ship those products to local logistics centers.

TireHub has tens of thousands of stock-keeping units; many are for older vehicles and are in low demand. The regional DCs also centrally stock slow-moving SKUs . RDCs can be viewed as a shock absorber. They allow demand variation and supply lead-time variation to be pooled, resulting in higher service and more efficient inventory. Inventory carrying costs would be far too high if all SKUs were stocked at the TLC level.

RDCs operate six days a week; they are not open on Sundays. The regional distribution centers receive 15 to 30 trucks a day and ship 15 to 30 out every day. High-volume TLCs receive 10 loads a week, two a day on most days. Smaller TLCs only get three truckloads a week.

Potential customers tend to ask for the brand of tires that are already on their car. However, if a dealer or other retail outlet is out of that item and can get a similar tire from a different manufacturer more quickly, they often suggest the competing brand to the customer. The customer usually agrees.

To not lose sales, TireHub has implemented a two-stage promise. If a customer wants to buy a tire and the local TLC is out but the closest RDC has it, TireHub will promise the customer they can have it by lunchtime the next day. For TLCs empowered to make the next-day promise, they will get an early morning shipment regardless of that local center’s replenishment needs.

TireHub and Demand Collaboration

When the combination was announced , it was also argued that a larger company, with more sophisticated IT, could better help dealers manage the growing complexity of SKU proliferation in the tire business. Connecting supply to demand in real time meant building a B2B portal for smaller retail customers and independent dealers. TireHub created the B2B portal from scratch. This made virtual inventory visible, a key enabler of fast, accurate deliveries.

For larger customers, TireHub integrated directly into the customer’s point-of-sale systems using application programming interfaces (APIs) and microservices. This drove more seamless communication. Many dealerships use a third party to facilitate the buying process. The company also needed to integrate with these third parties to provide connectivity and convenience to their customers. The firm customizes these integrations based on customers’ unique needs.

From the beginning, TireHub realized that growth depended on making it easier for companies to do business with them. When the company was formed, 60 percent of orders came in through the phone. Today, most orders come in through APIs or the portal. Growth has come from connectivity.

TireHub and Inventory Planning

When you are a distributor, your “core business is inventory,” according to Derek Poole, the vice president of supply chain and inventory strategy at TireHub. Mr. Poole has been at TireHub since 2021.

Before he arrived, the company selected a supply chain planning supplier, Tools Group , to improve service levels while at the same time holding less inventory. That relationship began in 2018. Before 2018, both Bridgestone and Goodyear used proprietary planning tools. They sought a software supplier with deep distribution expertise. Within a year, they selected and deployed Tools Group.

Demand planning in this supply chain is difficult because of both the number of products (SKUs) and seasonality. The planning model accounts for seasonality; for tire distributors, peak demand occurs when the weather starts to turn cold, so forecasts increase. Seasonality also affects which SKUs are sold; snow tires, for example, are not needed in the summer.

But the tool also uses point-of-sale data to track local demand; It uses syndicated data to understand which cars are in operation in a zip code, and which tires were part of those vehicles’ original equipment. In some cases, the company also uses weather data to improve short-term replenishment forecasts.

From Poole’s perspective, key Tools Group functionality includes forecasting at the customer-item-location level, for them this is the TLC level. He points to another advantage of the solution: “Supply chain planning tools usually function well in long-range planning. Tell me what’s going to happen in the next three to six months at a macro level.” They use the long-term forecast in their S&OP process . “What they often don’t do well is (forecast) at that supply chain execution level,” which involves forecasting replenishment needs in daily buckets. “I’ve actually been very pleased with being able to do both in Tools Group.”

Forecasting accuracy can be measured in different ways. The most complex forecast is the bottom-level forecast, as measured at the item/TLC level. TireHub measures forecast accuracy using MAPA – mean absolute percentage accuracy (this is an inversion of MAPE ). Before using the demand planning tool, their forecast was accurate 15% of the time. After the implementation, forecast accuracy improved almost immediately; jumping into the high 20s.

Forecasting accuracy did dip during the COVID years. People were driving less, so the industry reduced stock levels. Longer lead times also hindered inventory availability. But after COVID, things again improved at TireHub.

After the COVID shock, accuracy has climbed into the low 30s. While a forecast that is fully accurate only 30% of the time might sound low, for item/level forecasts that include large numbers of slow-moving SKUs, it is exceptional. Mr. Poole believes this is best-in-class performance.

When demand aggregation occurs and forecasts are made on pooled inventory, forecasts will always improve. Their regional distribution-level MAPA started at about 50% and rose to the mid-80s.

Tools Group’s primary measure of inventory quality is sales at risk. TireHub has a stringent measure of lost sales. They forecast daily demand at the TLC level. If an item is in stock, it’s not at risk. If it’s out of stock, it is. Back in 2019-20, right after implementation, sales at risk ran between 25 and 28%. Sales at risk is the inverse of service level; thus, their service level is between 72% and 75%.

“This year, we’re going to be at about 87% for the full year,” Poole exclaimed. “So, a really big improvement from an in-stock and service perspective.” That improvement is partly driven by the Tools Group application. Another factor is the opening of new regional distribution centers.

RDC Inventory turns have increased from 6 or 7 initially to 10 to 11 turns in the last couple of years.

Supply chain efficiencies have been driven by both building out an RDC network and using a robust inventory optimization tool. The network will continue to expand; next-day delivery performance will continue to improve as they bring up new regional DCs in the Midwest and Southeast.

TireHub will also upgrade its ToolsGroup application next year. The company is moving to the Cloud solution. The upgrade will bring a better user interface, driven partly by generative AI capabilities. SCP solutions generate huge amounts of data, and navigating the tool can mean going through layer after layer of analysis.

With generative AI, a user can say, ‘Hey, explain this!’ They can see which SKUs are consistently stocking out. The goal is 90% service. What has the service level been over time? If it is poor, why is that happening? Poole believes this is the core analytical capability and inventory analyst needs. He also believes that it is increasingly hard to find a planner who understands statistics and the math behind safety stock numbers; thus, he is excited by the new UI’s explanatory capabilities.

Then once a problem is identified, the obvious agentic application becomes ‘how do I fix it?’ “(We) usually have three levers: change the demand forecast because the demand forecast is inaccurate. Change a safety stock target.” Or figure out what is causing supply delays and change the lead time or lead time variability. “I’m not necessarily looking for an agent to tell me what that answer is, but I am looking for an agent to help make that a clear choice.” So, while new agentic capabilities are welcome, humans in the loop need to decide which lever to pull.

Poole ended the discussion by saying that Tools Group offers the best value in the market when you consider the price paid for the application versus the capabilities delivered.