GTA 6 Shatters Records as Review Bombers Target Metacritic Score
A Historic Financial Titan
Grand Theft Auto 6 has obliterated industry benchmarks, securing its place as a commercial juggernaut. Rockstar Games confirmed that the title generated an astounding $3.79 billion within its first 24 hours. To put this in perspective, the figure is more than quadruple the $800 million initial haul of its predecessor, Grand Theft Auto 5, which took three days to reach the $1 billion milestone. Remarkably, GTA 6 outperformed the entire lifetime theatrical gross of Avengers: Endgame—the highest-earning film in history—by nearly a billion dollars in just one day.
The Metacritic Paradox
Critically, the game is a masterpiece, tying the all-time record for the highest-rated video game on Metacritic with a 99/100 score, sharing the podium only with The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. However, GTA 6 achieved this with a volume of reviews seven times greater than its predecessor. Despite this critical acclaim, the game’s user score sits at a dismal 5.6/10, a figure that stands in stark contrast to the verified player sentiment on console storefronts, where it maintains a 4.83/5 on PS5 and a 4.9/5 on Xbox.
Anatomy of a Review Bomb
The discrepancy is the result of a calculated review-bombing campaign. Unlike platforms that verify ownership, Metacritic allows open access, enabling users to rate titles without proof of purchase. The current assault is driven by two primary factions:
- Fandom Rivalries: Supporters of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time have flooded the page with zero-score reviews to protect the legacy of their favorite title. This maneuver backfired, triggering retaliatory reviews that lowered the Zelda score, effectively pushing Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 into the top spot.
- Social Media Backlash: A vocal segment of the internet has targeted the game’s narrative, specifically criticizing the character dynamics between protagonists Jason and Lucia. These complaints are frequently accompanied by low-effort, AI-generated gibberish, and explicit displays of bigotry.
Technical Limitations and Reality
Beyond the coordinated negativity, a subset of legitimate criticism focuses on the game’s 30fps performance cap. Rockstar has addressed these concerns, noting that the sheer density of the game’s simulation makes 60fps technically unfeasible without stripping away core features like vehicle traffic and NPC density. With no PC release date in sight, this remains a point of contention for enthusiasts.
Ultimately, the Metacritic user score has become a hollow metric, rendered meaningless by bad-faith actors. While the online discourse remains heated, these efforts do little to impede the momentum of what is undeniably the largest entertainment launch in history.