I’m wondering how many investment wonks there are out there, who want to consider not just the spark of a startup’s potential, but the entire life cycle, including that gap between early funding and subsequent scaling of operations to arrive at vaunted blue chip status, if you will.

Presumably, there are quite a few, since starting an AI company is one of the last ways to succeed in this economy. If you are interested, you should check out this rundown of a talk I saw at Minds in Motion, the Imagination in Action event that happened here in Boston, in October.

The chat was with Abe Murray of AlleyCorp, Kristina Nilsson of J.P. Morgan, Isha Yerramilli-Rao of Bessemer Venture Partners and Aisling Carlson of Greentown Labs, with Tucker Hamilton, a perennial participant in our events, moderating. The group talked about various aspects of tech investing, with specific focus on that “gap” that confronts startup leaders, representing, in a way, the white water of business development.

One thing that panelists agreed on was that the market is frothy.

“There’s more people coming in,” Murray said. “More people from funds who wouldn’t have touched hardware are now investing in hardware, or deep tech, or whatever you call it, and they’ve moved beyond just funding the AI foundation model companies … I think that this moment is just getting started.”

Nilsson, who has a front row seat to all of this, agreed.

“There certainly is a tremendous amount of capital that used to be in SaaS, that went to digital AI, and is now migrating into physical AI,” she said, citing a big market, and early opportunity.

Nilsson mentioned that gap, explaining some of the fundamental theory of a business taking off.

“Scale is a key determinant for if you are able to attract more capital,” she added. “And I know there’s a circular reference between those two elements, but really, you have to prove you’re able to build a great technology, a great business that then gets more capital, which then enables you to build more technology. So if you’re an investor trying to place money and saying, ‘Okay, where can I find that gravity attention associated with’ … not being redundant, or replaced, or swapped out very easily, a vertically integrated solution, right now, is getting a lot of interest.”

“I think this is really just the beginning for the broader physical AI domain, but also for deep tech,” Yerramilli-Rao said, explaining some of the calculus at work in her firm. “What we get excited by is when there’s a really clear order of magnitude improvement on the technical side, at the early stage, if we can see something that’s going to build an enduring business. I think this is really just the tip of the iceberg for several opportunities here to innovate. So (we’re) very excited to see what’s still coming.”

When it came to her turn, Carlson noted how as a climate tech incubator, her firm’s sector has been under pressure for a while.

“Climate has been having a bit of a tough time of it,” she said ruefully.

She pointed out some green shoots that Greentown Labs tends to look at.

“Some of the technologies that maybe have a dual lens,” she said, “climate and defense, for example, are finding it easier to raise money in today’s environment than they would have in, say, the frothy heydays of 2019, 2020, 2021, where, you know, climate was getting a lot of attention.”

There was a lot more in the talk, about funding rounds, strategic leverage, low capital choices, and more. Growth and performance were topics of discussion, and selling vertical solutions, and that flight from SaaS to physical AI.

“If you have to physically integrate the technology into your business in some way, it just presents a barrier to entry that is far greater than the pure play software,” Carlson said.

“I think, in this moment, more than ever before, it’s really important to have a thesis or an idea before you enter an investment conversation,” Yerramilli-Rao added, “because I think the market is so noisy and frothy right now. It’s almost too difficult to know, just based on an individual conversation.”

When Hamilton asked panelists if they use AI for some sort of analysis, the answer was a resounding ‘yes,’ with some qualifications.

“All day long,” Murray said. “I have GPUs in my basement. I do it all. I write code. My wife writes code. My kids all write code. It’s a ton of fun, and you can do a lot with it. … it’s awesome. And every time I feed it my best investments, it tells me don’t make them, unless I tell them that I really want to make it, then it says ‘make it. You’re the smartest person ever.’ And if I feed it the worst investments, it tells me to make them if I said I like them. So I think it’s a tool, but it’s not magic.”

Nilsson had a different take.

“Personally, I’m waiting for my humanoid to get delivered,” she said.

“I think we’d be foolish not to use it,” added Yerramilli-Rao. “That being said, I think it’s important not to lean into the ‘Claude knows all’ AI slop mindset. So, as investors, we want to maintain our alpha (position). I use (AI) all the time for things like evaluating Excel spreadsheets, but not really for my investment thesis.”

“We use it all the time,” Carlson said. “But again, it’s not the final decision maker, obviously. We often work collaboratively with different corporates that we work with, to evaluate some of the startups … and that’s really fascinating to have the commercial person, the engineering person, the you know the physicist, or whoever, all sitting around the table, and then having AI occupy another seat at the table alongside them.”

I thought that was a good end to the conversation. We’re going to see AI occupying any number of these kinds of seats, in the future. Let’s be ready.