When most of us picture a shark, we probably picture it a very specific color palette. Specifically, I mean the familiar shark pattern of “countershading,” where a species is a gray or dark color along its back (that blends into the water when seen from above) and a pale belly that helps conceal the animal from below. It is such a familiar shark pattern that seeing one without it can feel almost… unsettling. At Malpelo Island, Galápagos sharks are substantial predators, capable of reaching around 12 feet (3.7 meters) long, typically with that familiar gray-and-white coloration. But there are individuals who lack that pattern… and that is exactly what divers encountered on May 1, 2026 .

At a depth of about 79 ft (24 m) near La Nevera, a dive site at Malpelo Island, Colombia, an adult male Galápagos shark ( Carcharhinus galapagensis ) was filmed swimming alongside normally-colored individuals. The shark was estimated to be more than 8.2 ft (2.5 m) long and appeared sexually mature, but unlike its companions, its entire body and fins were white. What was even more bizarre is that its retina remained darkly pigmented. The sighting is unusual enough on its own, but what makes it especially interesting is that this is not the first white Galápagos shark documented at Malpelo! A previous study described an apparently albino female based on observations made in 2016 and 2019 , making it so that researchers now have records of two different unusually pigmented sharks from the same population. What is going on?!

To understand why a “white shark” (different from the great white shark, Carcharodon carcharias ) is scientifically interesting, it helps to understand how animal coloration works. In fish, color is produced by specialized cells called chromatophores and different chromatophores contain different pigments or reflective compounds. Melanophores produce melanin (which contributes to dark brown, gray and black coloration) and other cells help produce or reflect yellow, orange, blue and lighter colors. Albinism is different from simply being unusually pale, as it generally involves a severe reduction or absence of melanin production throughout the body. It can also affect the eyes, making them red or pink. In the Malpelo shark, researchers observed the absence of normal dark pigmentation across the body while the retina retained pigmentation but because external observations alone cannot definitively establish the underlying genetic cause, the researchers describe the shark as a probable case of albinism rather than treating the diagnosis as genetically confirmed. Not every white animal is an albino; leucism, for example, can reduce pigmentation in the skin while leaving the eyes normally pigmented and “hypomelanosis” is a broader term for reduced melanin. There are also conditions such as melanism, where animals produce excess melanin, and xanthism, which can result in predominantly yellow coloration.

As one can imagine, color is quite important in the animal world! For aquatic animals, pigmentation can influence camouflage, predator-prey interactions, communication and potentially reproduction. A shark that stands out against its surroundings might be easier for prey or predators to detect. But the newly observed is not a juvenile that had only recently entered the population. At its size, with very long claspers characteristic of sexually mature males, it survived into adulthood. It was also observed behaving normally among other Galápagos sharks. So if albinism can create disadvantages, how did this individual make it this far?

The answer may lie not in the white shark itself, but in Malpelo.

Galápagos sharks are widely distributed across tropical and subtropical oceans and occur around several isolated islands in this region, including Cocos, Galápagos and Malpelo. Animals that repeatedly return to the same locations can inadvertently create relatively isolated populations. Research on Galápagos sharks in the Galápagos Marine Reserve has already revealed genetic differences among island groups, with prior studies also finding relatively small effective population sizes (meaning that the number of individuals contributing genes to the next generation can be considerably smaller than the total number of sharks present). This means the genetic diversity passed into the next generation could be much lower than the headcount suggests. That is why small or isolated populations can face increased risks from genetic drift and inbreeding (when related individuals reproduce, increasing the likelihood that offspring inherit two copies of a recessive genetic variant). Some of these variants could and can affect pigmentation or development. The newly observed male had slight apparent malformations involving the lower lobe of its tail and the rear margin of its right pectoral fin while the previously reported female did not show obvious body malformations.

This does not mean that the two white sharks at Malpelo prove inbreeding is occurring. They do not, and the researchers are careful to point out that other explanations are possible, including genetic mutations or environmental influences. But genetic, biochemical, reproductive and movement studies would be needed to determine the cause. Still, finding two apparently albino individuals in the same localized population is worth paying attention to and asking questions about the genetic health of a population that spends much of its life in the vastness of the Pacific. Could the Malpelo population be more genetically isolated than we realize? Or are unusual pigment patterns genuinely more common there? The deceptively simple answer might be that divers have become better at spotting and recording them, too. And if that’s the case, then we need to tread carefully in how we interpret rarity. Because all-white sharks are so visually striking, they are more likely to catch a diver’s attention and end up on camera, meaning the growing number of reports of unusual shark pigmentation may partly reflect our growing ability to observe and document these rare animals. More divers, better cameras and easier access to underwater imagery mean that rare animals are much less likely to go undocumented.

But the Malpelo observations are a sort of unusual natural laboratory for studying how movement, reproduction and genetics interact in an ocean predator. So… what else is happening in this population that we have not yet learned to see?